Broadband phone comparison table
Use the chart below to compare four of the best broadband phone services: Packet 8, iConnectHere, and Vonage. All these services offer clear connections and cheap rates worldwide. Compare the details and read my brief reviews. Then click any of the providers' names to learn more and sign up online.
Service Plans and Costs |
||||
|
||||
Rating |
4.5/5 |
4/5 |
4/5 |
|
Plan 1: Home |
$19.99 unlimited |
$6.99 pay per min |
$24.99 unlimited |
|
Plan 2: |
$19.99 unlimited |
-- |
$14.99 500 min |
|
Plan 3: outside the USA |
See notes below |
$6.99 pay per min |
See notes below |
|
Plan 4: Business |
$39.99 unlimited |
-- |
$49.99 unlimited |
|
The number of minutes (or "unlimited") refers to calls to and from the USA and Canada. Only Packet 8 and iConnectHere deliver phone adapters to international addresses. Packet 8 is available worldwide, but the $19.99 plan is reduced to 1000 minutes per month outside the USA. Vonage is available but not encouraged outside the USA. Packet 8 has a 49.99 "global" plan with unlimited min to a long list of countries. iConnectHere has a 24.99 "worldwide" plan with 250 minutes to a list of countries. |
||||
Local # in the USA |
Yes |
Yes |
Yes |
|
Non-USA Local # |
No |
Yes $7.99/mth |
No |
|
Free Adapter |
Yes |
Yes |
Yes |
|
Shipping Adapter |
Free shipping to USA |
$4.99 shipping worldwide |
Paid shipping to USA only |
|
Phone or adapter type |
Uses Packet 8 phones and adapters |
Linksys PAP2 or Cisco ATA compatible |
Variety of phones and adapters |
|
Int'l Rate Examples |
Australia 3¢ Brazil 4¢ China 3¢ India 16¢ Japan 4¢ Mexico 5¢ Philippines 19¢ Russia 7¢ Thailand 6¢ |
Australia 3¢ Brazil 6¢ China 3¢ India 16¢ Japan 4¢ Mexico 5¢ Philippines 14¢ Russia 6¢ Thailand 9¢ |
Australia 5¢ Brazil 9¢ China 10¢ India 17¢ Japan 6¢ Mexico 6¢ Philippines 18¢ Russia 12¢ Thailand 12¢ |
|
| *Some plans from Packet 8 and iConnectHere include free int'l calling in the monthly fee. Check each provider's website for current rates. Calls to specific cities and cell phones (or premium numbers) may be charged at higher rates. | ||||
Special Features |
||||
Toll Free Number |
Yes |
Yes |
Yes |
|
Toll Free Rates and Fees |
$4.99/mth |
$6.99 10¢/min |
$4.99/mth 4.9¢/min |
|
|
Packet 8: 100 min of free incoming calls then 4.5¢/min iConnectHere: 60 min of free incoming calls then 10¢/min |
|||
fax send, Receive |
Yes |
Yes |
Yes |
|
|
Faxing is still unreliable with broadband phone services, with results depending on the type of fax machine and other factors. | |||
3-Way Calling |
Yes |
Yes |
Yes |
|
Keep Own Phone # |
Yes |
Yes |
Yes |
|
|
This only applies for users living in the USA. You may not be able to keep your current phone number depending on where you live and your local phone company. It may take up to 30 days to transfer your number to the broadband phone service. | |||
Add'l Local Numbers |
Yes $4.99/mth |
No |
Yes $4.99/mth |
|
911 Service |
Yes |
Yes |
Yes |
|
e911 |
Yes $1.99/mth |
Yes Free |
Yes $1.50* |
|
|
911/ E911 services apply for users living in the USA. These features may only be available in specific locations, and broadband phone providers really cannot guarantee they will work. You should have an alternative means to call 911. Check with the providers carefully if this is an important issue for you. E911 means that when you dial 911 the operator will see your exact location displayed on a screen. This is very important to increase the response time in an emergency. You must go online and setup the E911 feature for it to work. *Vonage charges a $1.50/mth "regulatory recovery fee" to cover the cost of E911 and other services. They don't mention this fee upfront, and it's hard to find. I've included it here because this is the most applicable place on this comparison. |
|||
Extra Features Included in the Basic Service |
||||
Free Calls to other users |
Yes |
Yes |
Yes |
|
|
All these providers offer unlimited free calls worldwide to the broadband phones of other people using the same service. | |||
Voice Mail |
Yes |
Yes |
Yes |
|
Call Forward |
Yes |
Yes |
Yes |
|
Call Wait |
Yes |
Yes |
Yes |
|
Disable Call Wait |
Yes |
Yes |
Yes |
|
Caller ID |
Yes |
Yes |
Yes |
|
411 |
Yes 75¢/call |
Yes |
Yes 79¢/call |
|
Do Not Disturb |
Yes |
Yes |
Yes |
|
Caller ID Blocking |
Yes |
No |
Yes |
|
Anon Call Blocking |
Yesl |
No |
Yes |
|
Account Management, Billing and Payment |
||||
Mang Acct Online |
Yes |
Yes |
Yes |
|
Payment Options |
Auto billing to credit card |
Auto billing to credit card |
Auto billing to credit card |
|
Set Up Fee |
$29.99 |
$29.99 |
$29.99 |
|
| *iConnectHere: Gives you a $30 credit on your account at sign up to offset the activation fee. | ||||
Cancel Policy |
30 day guarantee |
30 day |
30 day guarantee |
|
Cancel Fee |
No* |
No* |
No* |
|
|
*Packet 8: Full refund if you cancel within 30 days and return the hardware in original condition. From 30 days to 12 mths a $59 fee applies for regular service (a higher fee for video phone service). See the "Terms of Service" for details. |
||||
Sign Up Link |
||||
Reviews |
||||
Important: You are responsible to read each provider's "Terms of Service" and verify information in this broadband phone comparison. Rates, terms, and other details are always subject to change, and I cannot guarantee any of the information above will be accurate when you read this page. |
||||
